Don't Overemphasize ROI as Single Measure of Success
Variety Counts: It Takes More Than One Benchmark to Assess Overall Effectiveness
Everyone loves to talk about ROI. The benchmark has firmly planted itself in the soil of marketing doctrine, widely accepted as a measure that makes it simple to evaluate marketing programs and gauge spending levels. Return on investment enables financial types to evaluate marketing initiatives with the same approach they use to evaluate capital expenditures and acquisitions.
But to us, there is a fundamental problem with overemphasizing ROI as the single measure of marketing success: It is often impossible to accurately quantify the impact. Although the world of marketing has come a long way in terms of analytic capabilities, applying financial numbers to the marketing equation is not always possible or preferable. That's why using ROI to evaluate the overall effectiveness can be a problem.
Take branding, for example. For many companies, brands are their most valuable assets. Determining the precise value of a brand at any given moment, however, is near impossible. Many companies do attempt to value brands. Interbrand and BusinessWeek, for example, produce a ranking of global brands each year based on brand value. Yet these brand valuation calculations generally rely on an assumption, built on an assumption, built on another assumption, built on, yes, another assumption. That means that trying to determine the impact of a TV spot on a brand's value or equity might produce numbers that are directionally right but certainly not precise.
Assuming brand impact
If the value of a brand cannot be precisely calculated, and thus known, then it would appear impossible to use solely ROI to evaluate the decisions that impact the brand. Either the impact on the brand has to be ignored, which seems incorrect, or it has to be put in as an assumption, which makes the analysis suspect.
That creates the potential for suboptimal decision making. Consider, for example, a company evaluating a cost-reduction idea. The capital cost is known, and the savings are known. The exact impact on the brand, however, cannot be determined quantitatively. Will anyone notice the change? Will it affect how they feel about the brand? How will sales and profit be affected? When will all this occur? All these questions can be hard to answer.
So on one side of the debate are certain, quantifiable savings. On the other side of the debate are qualitative concerns that the brand might suffer. A sharp finance executive could simply ask, "Well, what is the impact on the brand? Let's just factor that into the ROI calculation." The problem is that factoring this in with any precision is difficult, making the results of any analysis incomplete at best and misleading at worst.
Branding isn't the only area where returns are hard to evaluate. Customer satisfaction, loyalty, employee morale and differentiation are all important but generally impossible to put into hard financial numbers that can be used on a day-to-day basis when calculating ROI.
Super Bowl impact
Given these observations, it would seem that attempting to calculate the precise ROI on a Super Bowl spot, for example, would be a futile task. Certainly the cost is known, and it is rather substantial. But the returns are impossible to fully quantify. Consider Budweiser's recurring and considerable commitment to the Super Bowl. What is the net impact of Budweiser's appearance on consumers' affinity for the brand, the morale of employees, the motivation of distributors and the differentiation of the brand? While all of these elements are important to building a brand, they are generally impossible to put into hard figures that can be used to calculate an accurate amount.
Some marketing initiatives are easier to quantitatively measure than others. For example, a short-term price promotion generally has a substantial and immediate impact on sales. That makes calculating the return a fairly straightforward process. Similarly, online-advertising initiatives and coupons are often easier to evaluate with ROI. New-product initiatives may also be easier to evaluate using ROI, though as Clay Christensen, Stephen Kaufman and Willy Shih warn in their recent Harvard Business Review article, the calculation is often misused.
But here's the danger: A company that uses ROI to guide marketing decisions might focus only on initiatives that come with strong, quantifiable returns. The company might then reduce spending on programs that build the brand, increase customer loyalty and strengthen differentiation. That can be dangerous in that it increases the focus on short-term initiatives at the potential expense of more-valuable long-term gains.
'McStarbucks'
There's no clearer example of this than Starbucks. Over the past several years, the ubiquitous coffee chain has rolled out a series of initiatives to boost short-term profits at the risk of potentially damaging the brand. The ROI on each decision was probably very positive. But as CEO Howard Schultz admitted, the initiatives have hurt the brand and weakened the company overall. The new breakfast sandwiches, for example, might generate incremental revenue, but leave the stores smelling like cheese factories and make the baristas feel like they are working at McDonald's. As one rather frustrated barista noted on a recent visit, "Welcome to McStarbucks."
This is not to suggest that marketing should be a black box, where money is spent in a haphazard manner on programs that may or may not make any sense at all. Marketing decisions do need to be made strategically, and a marketing executive should manage and be evaluated on the overall financial performance of a business. But rather than focus on ROI, executives need to use a variety of measures to evaluate marketing programs' success. Those measures should be grounded in the objectives for a particular initiative. For example, if the goal is to strengthen customer loyalty, then loyalty should be measured and tracked. Anyone advertising in the Super Bowl needs to have clear objectives and a clear strategy, along with some way to evaluate success with respect to these strategies.
So what should managers do when asked to produce the ROI for a marketing initiative? Take a more open-minded approach to measurement, first focusing on a company's objectives and strategies and then identifying measures that can best work for them. Focusing solely on ROI is dangerous and naïve.
TRACKBACK :: http://yummythinking.com/tt/trackback/65
-
Subject: buy valium
Tracked from buy valium 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/docs/buy-valium buy valium
2009/04/13 05:12 -
Subject: jc whitney
Tracked from jc whitney 삭제http://studentrugby.com/wmv/misc/jc-whitney jc whitney
2009/04/13 05:26 -
Subject: buy viagra
Tracked from buy viagra 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-viagra buy viagra
2009/04/20 03:20 -
Subject: buy tramadol
Tracked from buy tramadol 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-tramadol buy tramadol
2009/04/20 03:29 -
Subject: tramadol hcl
Tracked from tramadol hcl 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/tramadol-hcl tramadol hcl
2009/04/20 03:37 -
Subject: tramadol online
Tracked from tramadol online 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/tramadol-online tramadol online
2009/04/20 03:46 -
Subject: buy ultram
Tracked from buy ultram 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-ultram buy ultram
2009/04/20 03:55 -
Subject: buy soma
Tracked from buy soma 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-soma buy soma
2009/04/20 04:04 -
Subject: order soma
Tracked from order soma 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/order-soma order soma
2009/04/20 04:17 -
Subject: buy carisoprodol
Tracked from buy carisoprodol 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-carisoprodol buy carisoprodol
2009/04/20 04:25 -
Subject: buy fioricet
Tracked from buy fioricet 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-fioricet buy fioricet
2009/04/20 04:34 -
Subject: buy valium
Tracked from buy valium 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-valium buy valium
2009/04/20 04:43 -
Subject: xanax online
Tracked from xanax online 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/xanax-online xanax online
2009/04/20 04:52 -
Subject: buy xanax
Tracked from buy xanax 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-xanax buy xanax
2009/04/20 05:02 -
Subject: vardenafil
Tracked from vardenafil 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/vardenafil vardenafil
2009/04/20 05:10 -
Subject: order cialis
Tracked from order cialis 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/order-cialis order cialis
2009/04/20 05:18 -
Subject: cialis online
Tracked from cialis online 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/cialis-online cialis online
2009/04/20 05:27 -
Subject: buy cialis
Tracked from buy cialis 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-cialis buy cialis
2009/04/20 05:42 -
Subject: buy levitra
Tracked from buy levitra 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-levitra buy levitra
2009/04/20 05:50 -
Subject: buy propecia
Tracked from buy propecia 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-propecia buy propecia
2009/04/20 05:59 -
Subject: buy meridia
Tracked from buy meridia 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-meridia buy meridia
2009/04/20 06:09 -
Subject: buy phentermine
Tracked from buy phentermine 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-phentermine buy phentermine
2009/04/20 06:18 -
Subject: phentermine
Tracked from phentermine 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/phentermine phentermine
2009/04/20 06:29 -
Subject: tramodol
Tracked from tramodol 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/tramodol tramodol
2009/04/20 06:49 -
Subject: tadalafil
Tracked from tadalafil 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/tadalafil tadalafil
2009/04/20 06:58 -
Subject: buy ephedra
Tracked from buy ephedra 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/buy-ephedra buy ephedra
2009/04/20 07:05 -
Subject: sildenafil citrate
Tracked from sildenafil citrate 삭제http://cipla.com/misc/rx/sildenafil-citrate sildenafil citrate
2009/04/20 07:13 -
Subject: burberry handbag
Tracked from burberry handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/burberry-handbag burberry handbag
2009/04/21 10:24 -
Subject: chanel handbag
Tracked from chanel handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/chanel-handbag chanel handbag
2009/04/21 10:38 -
Subject: chloe handbag
Tracked from chloe handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/chloe-handbag chloe handbag
2009/04/21 10:52 -
Subject: coach handbag
Tracked from coach handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/coach-handbag coach handbag
2009/04/21 11:06 -
Subject: coach purse
Tracked from coach purse 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/coach-purse coach purse
2009/04/21 18:28 -
Subject: designer handbag
Tracked from designer handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/designer-handbag designer handbag
2009/04/21 18:38 -
Subject: designer purse
Tracked from designer purse 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/designer-purse designer purse
2009/04/21 18:55 -
Subject: dooney bourke handbag
Tracked from dooney bourke handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/dooney-bourke-handbag dooney bourke handbag
2009/04/21 19:02 -
Subject: fendi handbag
Tracked from fendi handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/fendi-handbag fendi handbag
2009/04/21 19:11 -
Subject: gucci handbag
Tracked from gucci handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/gucci-handbag gucci handbag
2009/04/21 19:20 -
Subject: guess handbag
Tracked from guess handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/guess-handbag guess handbag
2009/04/21 19:29 -
Subject: juicy couture handbag
Tracked from juicy couture handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/juicy-couture-handbag juicy couture handbag
2009/04/21 19:39 -
Subject: leather handbag
Tracked from leather handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/leather-handbag leather handbag
2009/04/21 19:49 -
Subject: louis vuitton handbag
Tracked from louis vuitton handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/louis-vuitton-handbag louis vuitton handbag
2009/04/21 19:58 -
Subject: marc jacobs handbag
Tracked from marc jacobs handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/marc-jacobs-handbag marc jacobs handbag
2009/04/21 20:07 -
Subject: prada handbag
Tracked from prada handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/prada-handbag prada handbag
2009/04/21 20:18 -
Subject: replica designer handbag
Tracked from replica designer handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/replica-designer-handbag replica designer handbag
2009/04/21 20:27 -
Subject: replica handbag
Tracked from replica handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/replica-handbag replica handbag
2009/04/21 20:38 -
Subject: wholesale handbag
Tracked from wholesale handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/wholesale-handbag wholesale handbag
2009/04/21 20:47 -
Subject: wholesale purse
Tracked from wholesale purse 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/wholesale-purse wholesale purse
2009/04/21 20:56 -
Subject: louis vuitton replica
Tracked from louis vuitton replica 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/louis-vuitton-replica louis vuitton replica
2009/04/21 21:06 -
Subject: coach replica
Tracked from coach replica 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/coach-replica coach replica
2009/04/21 21:16 -
Subject: chanel purse
Tracked from chanel purse 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/chanel-purse chanel purse
2009/04/21 22:20 -
Subject: louis vuitton purse
Tracked from louis vuitton purse 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/louis-vuitton-purse louis vuitton purse
2009/04/21 22:33 -
Subject: hobo handbag
Tracked from hobo handbag 삭제http://sussdesigns.com/intro/misc/hobo-handbag hobo handbag
2009/04/21 22:47 -
Subject: Fight my brute!
Tracked from Fight my brute! 삭제http://devillie.mybrute.com Fight my brute!
2009/05/01 10:38 -
Subject: online education and college degree
Tracked from online education and college degree 삭제http://online-degree-edu.blogspot.com/ online education and college degree
2009/09/05 22:44 -
Subject: Online College Degree Distance Education
Tracked from Online College Degree Distance Education 삭제http://www.santafe.edu/events/workshops/index.php/User:Online-Degree Online College Degree Distance Education
2009/09/06 22:15 -
Subject: Casino 1269771495
Tracked from Casino 1269771495 삭제Casino 1269771495
2010/03/28 20:51
댓글을 달아 주세요